By Sandeep Mittal
Seeing
well without contact lenses and glasses is the
dream of millions of Humans and modern medical
science has enabled that dream to come true (Caster,
8).
If
surgical procedures were movies, LASIK would be
this years box office smash as it has received
much media coverage and many praises; however,
not that many people know what LASIK is, what the
advantages and disadvantages are, and most
importantly if LASIK is right for them (Buratto,
1). LASIK is basically a type of laser surgery
which can help correct nearsightedness (myopia),
which is the inability to see distant objects,
farsightnedness (hyperopia), which is the
inability to see close, and astigmatism, the
inability to focus light waves evenly. LASIK has
grown greatly in the last year, mostly because of
4 reasons; it is fast (procedure takes about 5-10
minutes), safe, painless, and the results are
almost always prolific.
The eye is just like a camera
because it works by focusing light waves that
pass through it. Light rays that enter the eye
must first pass through the most outer layer of
the eye called the cornea. The cornea performs 2/3
of the focusing process, the remainder of is then
completed by the crystalline lens which further
focuses the light on the retina. This requires
extreme precision in that the focused light must
fall exactly at the level of the retina (Gallo,
126). The retina is a nerve tissue that carpets
the inner surface of the eye, much like wallpaper
covers all aspects of a wall. The retina converts
the light into electrical signals, which are
transmitted to the brain by the optic nerve. Just
as a camera cannot produce clear photographs of
the image if the incoming light is not focused on
the film, we cannot produce a clear vision if the
cornea and crystalline lens do not focus the
light precisely on the retina. This is where
LASIK steps in.
A laser is a device that creates a
very special kind of light energy that is usually
invisible to the human eye (Caster, 16). In
LASIK, ophthalmologists use a certain type of
laser called the excimer. By using invisible
ultraviolet light, the excimer is able to break
covalent bonds between molecules. What sets
excimer aside from other lasers used in medicine
is the wavelength used. At one-hundred ninety-three
nm (nanometers), excimer lasers remove tissue by
breaking the covalent without creating much
thermal energy (Slade, 25). This allows for
precise removal of tissue with minimal
surrounding tissue damage. The very thin layer of
the cornea that is removed, changes the curvature
of the cornea ever so slightly, thus then results
in a change in the light focusing ability. In
nearsightedness (myopia), light rays from distant
objects are not focused on the retina, but
instead they are focused in front of the retina (See
Figure 1). Therefore to correct nearsightedness
in a LASIK procedure, the curvature of the cornea
must be decreased or in another words made
flatter by removing corneal tissue in a disc-shaped
pattern, or from the central cornea. A computer
determines the exact pattern and number of pulses
that are needed to do this. In farsightedness (hyperopia),
light rays from distant objects are focused not
onto the retina, but behind it (See Figure 1). To
correct this, the central portion of the cornea
must be made steeper; and this is accomplished by
removing corneal tissue in a donut shaped
pattern, or in another words more from the
peripheral areas. Eyes with astigmatisms focus
light waves unevenly because of the irregular
shape of the cornea; football shaped as opposed
to the usual round, basketball shaped corneas.
The excimer laser can remove corneal tissue
asymmetrically, and so the end result is a round,
symmetrical surface (Sloat, 90).
LASIK, did not just develop suddenly
overnight in some ophthalmologists mind;
however, LASIK is part of an evolved procedure (Gallo,
127). Todays vision correction revolution
dates back decades through the sheer genius,
persistence, and ingenuity of Professor Jose
Barraquer (Slade, 8). Refractive surgery, which
is the type of surgery LASIK is characterized as,
started in Bogota, Columbia in 1948 when
Barraquer started performing a procedure called
Freeze Keratomileusis. This procedure involved
adding a disc of corneal tissue (donated from
another person) with a predetermined curvature in
the cornea giving it structure. In a journal
found 2 decades after this procedure, it stated
that patients who had myopia could see better
after the procedure; however he stated a few
months after the surgery, that some patients
would lose their eyesight due to infection. The
reason for this was that Barraquer used an
unsterilized shaver to cut the cornea. It was not
until the late 1970s that refractive
surgery resurfaced when US surgeons visited the
Soviet Union. The surgeons brought back a
procedure called Radial Keratotomy (RK) which
made spokelike incisions in the cornea by using a
handheld diamond scalpel. The results were good,
but scientists noticed that the incisions
structurally weakened the eye.
Scientists and doctors worked for 2
decades to develop Radial Keratotomy into a
procedure that was both safe and produced good
results. Then in 1994, a company by the name of
Summit Technologies developed the first excimer
laser that could be used for surgery. A year
after, the Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
approved this excimer laser and stated that it
could only be used to correct mild
nearsightedness in a procedure called
Photorefractive Keratectomy (PK). In PRK,
surgeons scrape away the very outer layer of the
cornea (less than 5% thickness of the entire
cornea) and then use the excimer laser to
vaporize the underlying corneal tissue to a
predetermined depth (no more than fifty percent
thickness of the cornea). These results were very
good as 90 percent of the cases showed that the
patients achieved at least 20/40 vision, which is
the usual standard to pass a drivers
license test; however, the surgery had many
drawbacks. While the procedure itself was not
painful, patients had significant pain and
discomfort for almost a week after the surgery (Gallo,
129). Worst of all, it often took a week to even
see anything and six months to get the full
benefits of the surgery (Gallo, 129). Dr. Stephen
Slade, a refractive surgeon, summarized the
procedure well by saying, PRK works well,
but it hurts and the results take too long. To be
honest, patients dont like it.
Soon after PRK was introduced,
surgeons began testing a procedure called Laser
In-Situ Keratomileusis, which was first partially
introduced by the father of ophthalmology,
Barraquer in 1950 (Slade, 8). Keratomileusis is
derived from the Greek root keras (horn-like
cornea) and mileusis (carving) and basically it
is a procedure that involves slicing and peeling
back the outer layer of the cornea (anterior
cornea), leaving a hinge on one side, while the
laser sculpts the tissue underneath (corneal
stroma). After the excimer laser is done, the
flap is placed back to where it was before, and
no stitches are needed because the corneal flap
heals by itself when left to dry. You are
probably wondering if they still used the diamond
scalpel, and the answer thankfully is not.
Surgeons use a very precise instrument called the
microkeratome (See Figure 3) which makes LASIK
very unique compared to other surgeries. This
device is a mechanical shaver that has a sharp
blade, which moves back and forth at very high
speeds (See figure 2). After a suction ring has
been placed on the cornea, the microkeratome is
place on top of the cornea and advances across it
at very small increments creating a flap that is
only 1/3 inch in diameter. This instrument cuts
the cornea at a uniform thickness and creates a
portion of the cornea uncut. After the suction
ring and the microkeratome have been removed, the
corneal flap is folded back (See Figure 4),
exposing the middle portion of the cornea. Also
in LASIK surgery, the excimer laser can be used
at different frequencies and therefore produce
different desired results in the same patient.
Each laser pulse in a LASIK procedure removes ten-millionths
of an inch of corneal tissue in twelve-billionths
of a second while in a PRK procedure, the laser
removes about twice as much in about the same
time. The amount of corneal tissue removed
depends on how nearsighted or farsighted the
patient is (Gorman, 60). The more nearsighted a
patient is the more tissue must be removed to
obtain a flatter cornea, and the same goes with
farsightedness, except the cornea has to be made
steeper.
Back when Barraquer started Keratomileusis In
Situ, he noticed that he was having great success
with patients who had myopia and did not know why
patients who had hyperopia and astigmatism were
not enjoying the same results. Surgeons even
today notice, that after LASIK, patients who have
myopia before the surgery get better results than
patients who have other vision ailments (such as
hyperopia, astigmatism, and presbyopia) (Gallo,
128). Ophthalmologists now believe that the
reason has to do with how the excimer laser
reshapes the cornea (Gallo, 128). In a patient
who has myopia, the laser makes the cornea
flatter while in a hyperopic situation, the laser
makes the cornea steeper. The problem does not
come during the surgery but after it when the
cornea bed reshapes itself to match the new
cut cornea. They call it the cornea bed because
it is just like a bed because as you lie on a
mattress, it will reshape itself to the contour
of your body. Once the cornea is made flatter,
the cornea bed has no problem reshaping itself to
the new contour; however, this is not always the
case for hyperopia and astigmatism. The corneal
bed, which is located behind the outer layer of
the cornea, has trouble reshaping itself to
either a steeper or narrower shape.
Ophthalmologist do no fully understand why this
occurs, but they do urge that LASIK provides
better results for people who suffer from myopia
and therefore, that is why the vast majority of
people who undergo LASIK do so to correct
nearsightedness (Buratto, 9).
The results of LASIK are astounding (Gallo, 129).
The obvious goal of LASIK is to get a vision of
20/20, which is perfect vision. 20/20, 20/40, and
so on are measures of visual acuity; a person
with 20/40 needs to stand twenty feet away from
something that a person with 20/20 can see fine
from forty feet away. Last March, the Journal of
Ophthalmology stated that 3 months after the
surgery, seventy-percent of the patients who have
had LASIK, have 20/20 vision. A follow up 2 years
after the surgery showed that sixty-three-percent
kept the perfect vision while ninety-nine-percent
had at least 20/40 vision. The amount of vision
improvement generally is tied to the degree of
nearsightedness and farsightedness before the
surgery. Dr. Shravan Sharma, who is one of the
pioneers of LASIK said, The less
nearsighted or farsighted you are, the more
likely youll get 20/20. For low myopes,
ninety-five percent can get 20/20. For high
myopes, the figure might drop to sixty percent.
Usually, for every good thing that
comes along, there are some unfavorable
circumstances that follow; however, there are not
too many complications or side effects in LASIK (Shovlin,
113). Complications are very rare, but they will
be more common in patients with high
nearsightedness, farsightedness, and astigmatism
because they require more laser treatment. Also
no patient has ever become blind after a LASIK
procedure; however, there are a list of possible
complications that can result in decreased vision
after the surgery. One complication results from
the anterior cornea (flap) being placed unevenly
after the laser treatment, which usually results
in a corneal haze. Another possible complication
is that of an infection, which only occurs in .5
percent of the time. However, by far, the most
common complication is under or over correction,
which are due to the laser removing either too
much tissue or too little tissue respectively.
Under correction results from lack of corneal
tissue being removed and is usually fixed with a
procedure called touch up (another
mini LASIK procedure but without any further cuts).
If too much corneal tissue is removed, the
problem is a lot more serious because surgeons
must perform a Keratophakia, in which they have
to add corneal tissue. Under correction and over
correction are the main reasons that all patients
do not receive 20/20 vision, and that is why no
patient can ever be guaranteed perfect vision.
Last January, a review in LASIK of 1,062 eyes
found that complications occur in about 5 percent
of the cases. Tests before the procedure are now
being taken more seriously than before, because
those tests determine how much laser treatment is
needed.
While the recovery period of LASIK
is remarkably short, forty-percent of people who
had the procedure see halos or starbursts around
bright lights for several months (Buratto, 5).
Ophthalmologists believe this effect seems to be
caused by the edge created between the treated
and the untreated part of the cornea which bends
and distorts the light as it enters the eye.
Seeing halos or starbursts usually occurs during
night, when the pupil dilates and the edge of the
cornea falls right into view and for this reason,
people with exceptionally large pupils should not
undergo LASIK. These starburst effects, as
ophthalmologists call it, usually go away after a
few months.
Little research is available on
LASIKs long-term safety and effectiveness,
but there is information available on PRK. Last
year, a review in ophthalmology traced eighty-three
British patients who underwent PRK in 1990, and
found no serious complications in any of them.
This is attributed to the amount of untouched,
deep cornea (approximately fifty percent of the
entire cornea), which maintains the eyes original
overall shape. This is opposite of RK which left
only 10% of the untouched cornea (Voelker, 1494).
Despite its increasing popularity, LASIK is not
for everyone. People with extra-thin corneas are
not good candidates of this surgery because the
surgeon does not have enough tissue to work with.
Ophthalmologists also turn away people who have
rheumatoid arthritis and diabetes because they
have problems with dry eyes, and are hence poor
healers.
As people approach forty years old,
they begin to lose the ability to change their
focus from far to near (presbyopia), but dont
worry, it is natural in everyone. Baby boomers
who have LASIK to try to correct presbyopia,
usually trade their distance glasses in for
reading glasses (or vice versa). Surgeons are now
answering this problem with mono-vision,
which is correcting one eye for far distance and
the other for focusing on close distances. After
this procedure, the brain adapts, using each eye
for different functions; however, patients often
experience blurry midrange vision and have depth
perception problems. Most patients dont
mind it, but it drives some people nuts,
says Dr. Sharma.
There
is a revolution happening in vision correction,
says Dr. Rajiv Menon, a refractive
surgeon in New Delhi, and spokesman for
the Indian Society of Refractive Surgery. Were
seeing a stampede of people interested in a
surgical alternative. The question I ask
is, why not? Glasses can be very inconvenient,
and contacts can be a hassle, so why not venture
in this vast, growing field of LASIK? LASIK is
not just an eye operation anymore, it is a 2
billion dollar a year industry that has
revolutionized the way surgery is looked at.
Usually costing two thousand dollars per eye,
LASIK is not a surgery that anyone can afford,
especially since it is not covered by insurance.
Yet when asked, a LASIK patient consistently
states that the surgery was one, if not the, best
thing which they have ever done for themselves:
no worries of sleeping with contact lenses and
contracting a sight threatening infection (Slade,
254). No fear of scuba diving or swimming with
contacts, and no fear of waking up 3 a.m. after
having heard noises downstairs, and not being
able to find your glasses. LASIK surgery gave
Diane, a forty-five-year-old doctor assistant, a
newfound sense of freedom. Before the surgery,
she couldnt clearly see her feet when she
was in the shower, but now after LASIK, she is
taking rock-climbing lessons with her twelve-year-old
daughter; something she would have never done if
she were wearing glasses or contacts. Stories
like this are becoming common as Americans flock
to eye doctors at record rates for this surgical
fix. LASIK is blossoming like a flower in
the Fertile Crescent and soon everybody will be
taking advantage of its wondrous gift that it
provides; the gift of sight.
|